To determine if something qualifies as a trade journal, it should meet the following criteria that define its purpose and function within the trading process:

1. Record of Actual Trades

A trade journal documents the specific trades a trader makes, including details such as:

• Date and time the trade was opened and closed.
• Instrument/Asset traded (e.g., stocks, forex pairs, commodities).
• Entry and exit prices to track performance.
• Trade direction (buy, sell, long, or short).
• Position size and duration of the trade.

This is different from hypothetical trades or strategy planning — a trade journal focuses on actual, executed trades.

2. Analysis of Trade Performance

A trade journal not only logs trades but also includes performance metrics such as:

• Profit or Loss (P&L) on each trade.
• Return on Investment (ROI), or percentage gain or loss on the trade.
• Risk/Reward Ratio, to analyze how much risk was taken for the potential or actual reward.

The journal should provide measurable data to help evaluate your trading success over time.

3. Rationale for Trades

A key part of a trade journal is documenting the reasons behind each trade, which might include:

• Trade Setup: What strategy or technical indicators were used (e.g., moving averages, support/resistance levels)?
• Market Conditions: What was the market environment like at the time (e.g., trending, range-bound, volatile)?
• Entry and Exit Reasons: Why did you enter the trade, and what prompted the exit?

This reasoning helps traders learn from both successful and unsuccessful trades by identifying patterns and improving decision-making.

4. Emotional and Psychological Tracking

Many trade journals also include a section for documenting emotions during the trade, such as:

• Pre-trade feelings: Confidence, anxiety, excitement.
• During the trade: Whether you felt pressure to close early or experienced fear of missing out (FOMO).
• Post-trade reflection: Emotions following a win or loss, and whether emotions influenced decision-making.

A focus on emotions helps traders identify psychological triggers and improve discipline over time.

5. Learning and Improvement

A true trade journal includes a space for lessons learned from each trade:

• What went well, and what could be improved?
• Did the trade follow your strategy, or did emotions influence the decision?
• Were your risk management techniques effective?

This reflective component allows the trader to improve continuously and adjust their approach based on past performance.

6. Consistency

A trade journal should cover all trades, not just selective or high-profile ones. Consistent logging of trades ensures you have a comprehensive view of your performance over time.

7. Tracking Key Metrics Over Time

A trade journal typically helps traders monitor long-term trends and key performance indicators, such as:

• Win/Loss Ratio: The percentage of profitable trades vs. losing trades.
• Total Profit/Loss: Overall financial performance across all trades.
• Average Return per Trade: How much profit/loss you make on average per trade.
• Risk Management: How well you adhere to stop losses, and your overall risk exposure.

How to Spot a Trade Journal:

If a document or tool includes the following characteristics, it’s likely a trade journal:

• Detailed logs of real trades, including relevant information (dates, prices, and outcomes).
• Reflective analysis of trade decisions and strategies.
• Performance metrics that can be tracked and reviewed.
• Emotional insights that help refine trading discipline.
• Lessons and adjustments based on past trades for improvement.

If all of these elements are present, you can be confident that it is a trade journal. A spreadsheet, notebook, or digital platform like Trade Dash that fulfills these functions would all qualify as trade journals.

‍